candy canes

The Best Advice So Far - candy canes

I finally got my tree this week.

The front lot at Hanson’s Farm up the road glistened with new-fallen snow. They had fewer than a dozen trees left, having started with nearly two hundred just three weeks ago. This actually worked in my favor, given my longstanding tradition of choosing the Charlie-Browniest tree I can find — the one least likely to be picked due to some flaw or other.

Some I had to rule out on account of their being too tall or too fat to fit in the space, nestled between a window, the bookshelf and the low pitched ceiling in that corner of my second-story farmhouse living room.

Yet even with the further reduced selection, they all seemed perfect. Too perfect.

I gave them a second looking over and then a third, before deciding on the only one that appeared to have any gap at all in the branches — a little Fraser fir.

The owner, a kind-faced farmer with weathered skin and calloused hands, sold me the tree for just twenty dollars, including trimming the trunk by half an inch and settling my purchase into the trunk of my car.

It started to snow again on the drive home — that kind of gentle snow that looks like tiny perfect circles and falls straight down.

Once home again, I hoisted the tree onto one shoulder and edged my way up the narrow, steep stairs, seemingly without losing a single needle. As I settled the base of the tree into the heavy cast-iron stand, I noticed that the trunk was actually bent. I’d have to work a bit to get it to stay upright. I smiled. I’d chosen the right tree after all.

Lying on my back, branches outspread above me, I steadied the tree with one hand while turning the three keys bit by bit.


Tighten this one three times.


Loosen that one twice.

As I worked, my face mere inches from the stand, something rather magical happened. So cold was the tree still that, though the room was plenty warm and cozy, I could see my frosty breath.

At last, the tree was standing plumb.

I gave the frigid tree a day for its branches to settle. And by the next morning, the house was already permeated with the rich scent of evergreen. All of the water I’d poured just the night before was gone, having slaked the thirsty tree, and so I added more.

It was time to string the lights.

My lights are white, never the colored variety. No LEDs. No blinking. No fading. Just the old-fashioned, steady white bulbs — the kind where the whole strand goes out if one of them fizzles.

It’s very important that the lights wind deep inside the tree as well as to the tips of branches, as opposed to simply wrapping them round and round the outside. It gives the tree depth. And as much as possible, wires should be strategically hidden, since they break the magical effect.

Once the lights were in place — with just the right number remaining to weave into the wicker star on top — I gave myself an evening to enjoy the tree in that simple state.

Friday night, serenaded by Bing Crosby and the Andrews Sisters, I decorated the tree with ornaments spanning a lifetime.

A set of six intricately painted Fabergé-style eggs, unpacked from their rectangular, satin-lined case.

Cookie-cutter shapes — a holly leaf, a stocking, a gingerbread man and others — each made by hand with nothing but applesauce and generous amounts of cinnamon, and smelling exactly as you might expect them to.

Classic glass bulbs, their crackled gold paint casting multiple reflections.

And, of course, the candy canes.

Actually, the candy canes are the first to adorn the tree. There are only five left from the set of twelve that first decorated the tiny tree in my dorm room during my freshman year of college.

That makes them exactly three decades old this year.

And, yes — they are real candy canes.

When Chad was still in high school, I had a group of his peers over around Christmas time. The crowd was bigger than anticipated, so I ran out quickly to grab some more food. When I returned, Chad told me, a look of comical disgust on his face, “I think something’s wrong with your candy canes. I ate one of them. It tasted gross and it was chewy, like gum.”

That was ten years ago.

I struggled to remove them from their box this year. They were stuck to the cardboard in multiple places, their stripes barely recognizable any longer, having long since broken through their cellophane wrappers. I have to be careful about where I place them on the tree, as they do tend to slowly ooze down onto the branches beneath them.

On the heels of last week’s post, as well as comments I’d left in response to another recent post by my friend Sean, I found myself wondering … why do I feel compelled to keep these gooey, thirty-year-old candy canes in circulation?

I stared into the mesmerizing lights of this year’s tree for nearly two hours last night, contemplating this question.

Historically, I’m a perfectionist. I suppose I’ve done other things in life simply to keep an unbroken record. Even so, the deteriorating condition of the candy canes themselves ruled out this reasoning.

Next, I considered whether some remnant of OCD from years gone by might be the culprit. But all of my Christmas trappings are stored in a four-cubic-foot cubby. And I’m certain that, if someone were to suggest to me with any seriousness at all that they thought it might be hoarding or the like, I’d throw those candy canes away in a heartbeat, if only to spite them.

Was I holding onto the past in an unhealthy way? Yet as I regarded each collection of ornaments, it was immediately clear that none of them came from “happy golden days of yore.”

The eggs had been a gift from my friend Leigh Anne in 1992, one of the most difficult years of my life. Likewise, the cinnamon set was made by my friend Wendy and given to me in 1999 — another year fraught with major upheaval.

The tarnished gold bulbs had hung on the trees of my childhood — a period characterized in large part by fear and turmoil.

And the candy canes? Although I was a star student, the truth is I hated college. In fact, every single semester, I packed up all my things with no intention of ever going back, and only returning at the insistence of my mother who had some foresight at a time when I myself did not.

Was I attempting to sterilize a painful past, then? No, that wasn’t it. I can remember it all in vivid detail and call it what it was, though it has no real hold on me in the present.

So … what then? Why were those candy canes (or, for that matter, any of the other ornaments from hard times past) still decking my tree now?

At last, I arrived at an answer that felt like the truth.

My eyes wandered from the tree to the surrounding room.

On a window sill, a mason jar filled with nothing but curls of brown paper, a message tied around the lid with green-and-white-striped twine: “Unconditional Love.”

A miniature replica of the Eiffel Tower, which glows with multicolored lights when turned on.

Two cookbooks written by dear friends.

Everywhere I looked were tokens of love. And within that context, the reason for the candy canes became clear.

Whatever life has brought my way, I’ve chosen to hold onto the good in spite of the bad.

I’ve made consistent choices to surround myself with reminders of the wonderful people at each stop along the way, the diamonds among the coal, the proof that I’ve made it through — and that I will continue to do so, come what may.

And so I’ll keep those drippy candy canes as long as I’m able.


Simply put, because I choose joy.

The Best Advice So Far: Choose joy

Quick Link to Subscribe: Button

Quick Link to Comment: Button